7. Edition FAQs zum neuen Armeebuch Warriors of Chaos

Neueste Inhalte Folgen Zitieren
#2
Einige Antworten

Von Phil Kelly (angeblich)
Q: Should Deamon Prince, Hellcannon, Deamonic Mounts have magical attacks, they don't have it in the book?

A. No, they are different in this book.

Q: Do I receive a roll on Eye of The Gods Table when my hero with EotG rule kills an enemy champion (unit upgrade, not character in every means)?

A. Nope, that would be too powerful

Q: How we should count Victory Points for Hellcannon and its crew?

A. It is treated like a monster with handlers

Q: What is the correct movement rate of Hellcannon and its crew? Can Hellcannon move more than 6" as long as the dwarfs are in 1" from it?

A. Huh? Don't understand this one!

Q: When Hellcannon is charging, can we move hellcannon 12" and if the dwarfs don't have sufficient movement we will place them in the back of hellcannon as charging with a skirmishing unit?

A. You move at the speed of the slowest model in the unit. So a foot unit with a cavalry guy in it couldn't move as fast as the cav guy, same deal here.

Q: What is the proper base size for Disc of Tzeentch (old one has 50x50mm)?

A. Whatever we now sell it with I guess!

Q: Are Blood Crushing Roar and Word of Agony magical attacks?

A: No, otherwise they would say they were magical

Q: When we roll misfire on Hellcannon and then 3 (all spellcasters suffer a miscast), what will happen if we roll: 5-6, 10-11, 12 (can we cast our own spells, which spell we lose/cast with irresistible force)?

A: Roll for a wizard - if he rolls a 5-6 then the opponent gets to cast a spell. Otherwise resolve the effects but as there is no spell being cast it cannot be resolved with Irresistable Force etc.

Q: Can we target characters inside units with 1st spell from lore of nurgle

A: Yes

Q: Ensorcelled weapons - when we upgrade ensorcelled weapons to lances, what is the knights' Strength when they charge? S7 or S6? And in subsequent rounds of combat is it S5 or S4? Do attacks made with lances count as magical?

A: lances are not ensorcelled!

Q: In the AB it says: upgrade ensorcelled weapons to lances. Shouldn't it be 'swap' or 'change' rather? Word 'upgrade' might get people confused a bit (at least that happened to me Razz).

A: Yes, good call. Go for 'exchange' if you will.

Q: Favour of the Gods - when we give Favour of the Gods to Chosen champion, can we change the result on the Eye of the Gods table, which applies to the whole unit?

A: Yes

Q: What is the proper base size for Hellcannon?

A: I don't know the answer! Maybe 50x50 or a chariot base? Alessio might be able to help on this one...

Q: Can Hellcannon shoot after movement?

A: No

Q: Are the daemons of the proper god immune to effects of certain magical items (example: Festering Shroud) and spells (example Plague Sqall)?

A: No

Q: Is the model equipped with Necrolic Phylactery immune to the effects of demonic lore of Nurgle too?

A: No

Q: Does "Father of Blades" special effect (self-hits on 1's) works only against close combat hits or shooting too?

A: close combat

Q: Does the "Infernal Puppet" effect work on friendly wizards too?

A; Yes

Q: What is the proper base size of the warshrine?

A: Chariot

Q: If a character with mark of nurgle join unit without this mark, that unit also get -1 to shoot?

A: No

Q: How many power dice can a non sorcerer character use to cast a spell, when equiped with the book of secret?

A: 2

Q: Can you use both "shooting" gifts (Roar + Stream) and throw Death's head at the same time?

A; Yes

Q: Eye of the gods state that "Duplicate effects must be rerolled". Is the "Eye is closed" (nothing happens) considered an effect, therefore you reroll it if you get it for the second time? Or does the effect strictly means stupidity, +1 to charecteristic etc., therefore you could end up with two "eye is closed" rolls?

A: No

Q: Having stupidity from a spell or helm of many eyes, can you get it again from the Eye of the gods roll?

A: Yes
Zum Vergrößern anklicken....
 
#5
Schöne Zusammenfassung des Threads dort.

Ich finde es ganz schön erschreckend, wieviele Fragen es bereits gibt, bevor das Buch überhaupt veröffentlich wurde.

Einige Fragen entstehen aber meinem dafürhalten nach nur auf Grund eines übersteigterten Regelf**kens nach. Natürlich sind manchmal einige Sachen nicht hunderprozentig klar und mann kann vielleicht nicht immer erkennen, was genau gemeint ist aber manchmal kann man es auch übertreiben. Mit ein bischen gesundem Menscheverstand sollte man doch wissen, welche Absicht die eine oder andere Regel verfolgt (Bsp. Frage nach Lanzen bei Rittern).
 
#6
Meine Antworten

Quelle: ICH!!!
Begründung: Erfahrung und GMV.
Offen zur Diskussion.

Q1. Are duplicate results of "The Eye is Closed" rerolled?
Commentary : The rules for the Eye specify that any roll is a gift, and any duplicate gifts are rerolled.
S. WoC pp43
Nein, eine 7 wird nicht wiederholt, außer von Chosen.

Q2. If a large target flees or breaks and is run down, by a character, does the character get to claim the EotG bonus?
Commentary : The Eye of the Gods rule only specifies that the character cannot simply run down enemy characters to claim the bonus.
S. WoC pp43
Große Ziele und Helden sollten gleich behandelt werden, also Nein.

Q3. If a character is in a unit and an enemy model with the Large special rule is slain, must the character do the final wound to gain the roll on the Eye of the Gods table?
Commentary : The Eye of the Gods rule only specifies that the character must influct the final wound on characters.
S. WoC pp43
Kompromiss: Der Held muss das Monster zumindest einmal verwundet haben.

Q4. If the answer to the above is no, if more than one character is in a unit that kills a large target, do both the characters get to claim credit and roll on the EotG table?
S. WoC pp43
Nur der, der die letzte Wunde verursacht hat.

Q5. If a large target crumbles due to combat resolution (such as a zombie dragon, or greater daemon) does the character get to claim the EotG bonus?
S. WoC pp43
Nein, da hat man Pech gehabt (Oder auch Glück, immerhin ist der Große Dämon/Zombiedrache weg).

Q6. Does killing a champion in a challenge count for the EotG bonus?
Commentary : The rule specifies character, but it seems odd.
S. WoC pp43
RAW gilt es auch, wenn ich einen Truppchampion umhaue.

Q7. What happens if a troll or model with the Helm of Many Eyes (Stupid) rolls Stupidity on the Eye of the Gods table?
Commentary : The rules say that duplicate gifts are rerolled, but do not mention whether having the rule already counts as duplication.
S. WoC. pp43.
Blöd bleibt Blöd, nicht wiederholen.

Q8. How do rolls on the Eye of the Gods table affect mounts (either of characters or units blessed by the war shrine)?
Commentary : No indication is given either way. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp43
Gar nicht, es betrifft nur den Reiter.

Q9. If a character (with the Eye of the Gods rule) is involved in a combat where there are friendly champions (without the Eye of the Gods rule), must the character challenge or can the champion?
Commentary : The rules state that the character must issue a challenge where able, but if the champion challenges then the character cannot.
S. WoC pp43
Unsicher, aber ich denke, der Chaosspieler darf wählen, solange er überhaupt eine Herausforderung ausspricht.

Q10. Chosen: If at the beginning of the game, they roll a ‘2’ and then a ‘7’ are they stuck with that?
Commentary : Any dice may only be rerolled once.
S. WoC pp47
Solange wiederholen, bis der Würfel keine 2 oder 7 zeigt, steht meines Erachtens auch in dieser Form im Text.

Q11. On what size base should a Steed of Slaanesh be mounted?
Commentary : The Steed is a 1-wound mount, making it cavalry. Two models exist that could be the "Steed of Slaanesh", one comes with 25x50, the other 50x50. The notes on page 54 state that the other Gods' mounts and generic Daemonic mount are not mounted on 25x50mm bases, but make no mention of the Steed of Slaanesh.
S. WoC pp54
Beide Bases sind möglich, normalerweise ist das Mitgelieferte zu benutzen, ich empfehle aber den Umbau auf 50x50.

Q12. If the Warshrine grants an EotG roll to a unit with a character in it; does the character gain the bonus as well?
Commentary : The character is part of the unit, but the Warshrine does not specify.
S. WoC pp58.
Nein, das bringt nur Probleme und an anderer Stelle (bei den Chosen) werden angeschlossene Charaktermodelle vom Wurf ausgeschlossen.

Q13. If the Warshrine grants an EotG roll to a unit and the result is a duplicate to a previous roll a character or champion in the unit already has, should you re-roll it?
Commentary : Duplicates are rerolled, but technically the gift is not being given to the character/champion specifically
S. WoC pp58, 43
Siehe Q12: Ein Held bleibt sowieso unbeeinflusst. Ein Truppchampion sollte dann einfach noch einmal würfeln, damit er ein anderes Ergebnis erhält.

Q14. Does the Warshrine's Giver of Glory rule affect champions from both sides?
Commentary : The text does not specify "friendly".
S. WoC pp58
Nein, das bringt nur Probleme.

Q15. If the answer to the above is yes, what constitutes a "Chaos champion"? Do Daemons of Chaos and Beasts of Chaos count?
S. WoC pp58
Nein, das bringt nur Probleme, siehe Q14.

Q16. If the Warshrine is destroyed or otherwise removed from play, does the last unit to be blessed by it retain the gift?
Commentary : The rules say that rerolling the result for the blessed unit negates the previous effect, but they do not specify that the effect ends if the Warshrine is slain.
S. WoC pp58
Ja, der Segen bleibt erhalten.

Q17. Do wounds suffered by a Giant count to CR if they are subsequently healed by the Giant's Chomp attack in the same phase?
Commentary : On one hand they were still inflicted, on the other the Giant is not hurt by the time CR is calculated.
S. WoC pp65
Verwundungen zählen (unsicher).

Q18. If a giant rolls a double with "Thump with Club" and the combat ends that round, but he pursues/overruns into another combat, must he still forego his attacks in the next round of combat?
Commentary : Other effects specify they do not apply if the combat ends, the "stuck club" condition does not.
S. WoC pp65
Wenn er überrennt, sollte er seine Keule wieder aus dem Boden gerissen haben, darf also normal kämpfen.

Q19. If a Giant "Hurls" a rank and file model with multiple wounds, a ward save, or regeneration and it survives, what happens?
Commentary : The resultant model is separated from its unit, a condition that cannot normally occur.
S. WoC pp65
Er stirbt aus Einsamkeit (Keine Ahnung).

Q20. If a Giant "Hurls" a model, does it benefit from any protective banners (eg. Drakenhof) or abilities (eg. Locus of Nurgle) in its unit?
Commentary : It isn't clear when exactly the wound is suffered.
S. WoC pp65
Die Wunde erhält er vor dem Fliegen.

Q21. The Hellcannon is a monster but "fires like a stone thrower". Does this mean it is move-or-fire?
Commentary : The rules are not clear, please clarify.
S. WoC pp66
Bewegen oder Schießen.

Q22. Do Tomb King Liche Priests suffer a miscast if the Hellcannon rolls a 3 on its misfire chart?
Commentary : Liche Priests are wizards, but do not normally miscast due to their unusual magic. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp66
Ja, er erhält einen Zauberpatzer.

Q23. If a Hellcannon misfires rolls a 3, what happens if any wizards roll the result that the other player can cast a spell for free? How (if at all) can this be dispelled?
Commentary : As the Hellcannon will misfire in the shooting phase, their will be no power or dispel dice in play.
S. WoC pp66
Der Spruch gelingt automatisch und kann nur durch Bannrollen gebannt werden.

Q24. What base should a Hellcannon be on?
Commentary : The model is not supplied with a base, and the rules give no guidance. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp66
mindestens 50x50 (Monster-Größe).

Q25. Archaon's Chosen of the Gods rule says that "enemy are at -1 to hit with attacks in close combat". Does this apply only to attacks against Archaon?
Commentary : Ordinarily the text would say "attacks against [the model]", but this condition is absent. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp69
Nur gegen Archaon (er trägt ein Mal des Nurgle).

Q26. If Archaon releases U'Zuhl and rolls one or more 1's to hit, are any wounds counted to combat resolution, and if so which side benefits?
Commentary : Combat resolution is normally awarded to the side inflicting the wounds, but Archaon will be wounding his own side. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp69
Der Chaos-Gegner kriegt den Punkt.

Q27. Can Galrauch join units?
Commentary : Galrauch is a character, not a monster. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp70
Nein, das bringt nur Probleme, außerdem kann er fliegen.

Q28. Can Wulfrik use Seafang to enter the table with a unit of Marauder Horsemen?
Commentary : The description says "a single unit of Marauders". It is unclear whether this means Chaos Marauders, Marauder Horsemen, or both. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp74
Nein, nur Barbaren zu Fuß.

Q29. Is Starcrusher a magic weapon?
Commentary : This is important for various spells and effects that target magic weapons specifically.
S. WoC pp75
Ja.

Q30. Must Scyla issue challenges?
Commentary : Eye of The Gods specifies that Chaos Models must issue challenges if able, Scyla's Hero's Fate rule says she can issue challenges.
S. WoC pp76
Ja, Scyla muss herausfordern.

Q31. Chaos lores are treated "exactly the same as lores published in the warhammer rulebook". Does this mean that any model with the ability to choose a lore from the Warhammer Rulebook can choose a Chaos lore (eg Empire Battle Wizards)?
Commentary : Treating a lore exactly as if it appears in the Rulebook has many far-reaching consequences. Was this the intent?
S. WoC pp106
Nein, das bringt nur Probleme.

Q32. Do Sorcerors and Sorceror Lords have access to magical shields?
Commentary : The rules on page 106 say that sorcerors are unusual in that they wear chaos armour and use magical armour and shields like other champions, however they have no options for shields and so cannot buy magical shields.
S. WoC pp106
Ich gehe davon aus, dass Chaosmagier auch magische Schilde tragen können (ausnahmsweise), weil es explizit da steht. An dieser Stelle wäre weniger mehr gewesen, da es da steht, gilt RAW.

Q33. Do Daemon Princes that are given magic levels get Chaos Armour?
Commentary : The rules on page 106 say that sorcerors wear Chaos Armour, and Daemon Princes with magic levels are sorcerors.
S. WoC pp106
Nein, auf gar keinen Fall.

Q34. Does the phrase "single model" in Magnificent Buboes mean that the target must not be in a unit?
Commentary : This is the normal meaning of the phrase.
S. WoC pp107
Nein, das Ziel darf sich auch in einer Einheit befinden.

Q35. If the answer to the above is no, can the spell pick out characters in a unit? Can it be cast into combat?
Commentary : It isn't clear which, if any, targeting restrictions the spell must adhere to. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp107
Ja, einzelne Modelle können getroffen werden. Nein, wirkt nicht im Nahkampf, dazu müsste das extra dabei stehen.

Q36. Will Curse of the Leper automatically kill a war machine such as a cannon as soon as it is cast?
Commentary : Reducing a model's strength to 0 or less removes it from play. Most war machines have Strength 0, so Curse will reduce their strength to less than 0 immediately.
S.WoC pp107
Nein, Kriegsmaschinen sind immun dagegen.

Q37. Pandaemonium: If an enemy unit, character or spellcaster has magic resistance (such as a Bretonnian Damsel) can they use it when this spell is cast?
Commentary : MR applies if a unit is "affected" by a spell. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp108
Nein, denn sie werden nicht als Ziel ausgewählt und der Spruch hat auch keine Reichweite.

Q38. What happens if Call to Glory is cast on the last remaining non-character in a unit containing characters?
Commentary : An illegal unit would be formed as a result. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp108
Die beiden Modelle bilden eine Einheit, können sich bei Bedarf trennen.

Q39. What happens when Call to Glory is dispelled after the magic phase in which it was cast?
Commentary : The spell description says to remove the target from play and replace with an Exalted Hero. No guidance is given for what happens if and when the spell is dispelled.
S. WoC pp108
Q40. If Call to Glory is dispelled after the affected model has suffered a wound, what happens? Is the suffered wound carried over, possibly killing the (single wound) model?
Commentary : It is unclear what effects carry over between the enchanted and mundane model.
S. WoC pp108
Q41. Can a Call to Glory Exalted Hero leave the unit he is with?
Commentary : The model is a character, and would normally be allowed to do so.
S. WoC pp108
Q42. If the answer to the above is yes, what happens if the spell is dispelled while the Hero is away from his original unit?
Commentary : If the model reverts to non-character status, then he is separated from his unit illegally.
S. WoC pp108
Ich korregiere mich beim Spruch Call to Glory: Der Spruch sollte kein "Bleibt im Spiel"-Zauber sein, da dies nur Probleme bereitet. Einmal zum Erhabenen Champion berufen, sollte das Modell für den Rest des Spiels ein erhabener Champion bleiben, mit sämtlichen Rechten und Pflichten, während der Zaubernde weitere Sprüche wirken kann. Damit behebt man sämtliche Probleme.

Q43. Infernal Gateway: If this spell has strength 11+ and the target unit has a Vampire with the Ring of Carstein, does he get to use his ring?
Commentary : It is unclear whether special saves such as the Ring apply when a model is "removed from play". Please clarify.
S. WoC pp108
Unsicher, ich kenn den genauen Text nicht. Eigentlich müsste das Modell keinerlei Chance haben, wieder zu kommen.

Q44. Infernal Gateway: If this spell rolls a strength of 11+ does it affect the steam tank?
Commentary : The Steam Tank is immune to spells without a known strength. It is unclear whether the effect is S11/S12 or not. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp108.
Die Stärke ist 11/12, aber der Panzer wird nicht automatisch entfernt, dagegen ist er nämlich immun.

Q45. Does Hellshriek dispel spells that grant Immunity to Panic or Immunity to Psychology, as described under "Cancelling Spells"?
Commentary : Ordinarily, when two spells conflict directly in this way, the later spell dispels the first. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp109, BRB pp110
?

Q46. Is there any time limit on the Terror or attack allocation effects of Aura of Acquiescence?
Commentary : The spell only specifies a time limit for Fear. Please clarify. S. WoC pp109
Behandle Entsetzen wie Angst.

Q47. Mark of Nurgle: If a character w/MoN is in a unit with 5+ RnF models in it, do any shooters targeting the unit suffer the -1 to hit due to the MoN?
Commentary : It is unclear whether the character is being targeted in this case. Please clarify.
S. WoC 110
Nein, der Beschuss trifft die Einheit und das Mal überträgt sich nicht.

Q48. If a model with Word of Agony is in combat with a Dark elf unit containing an assassin, which occurs first - the Assassin's appearance or the use of the Word of Agony?
Commentary : Both occur "at the beginning of the combat phase" with no guidance on priority. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp110, DE pp61
Drum würfeln.

Q49. Do wounds inflicted by Word of Agony count towards combat resolution?
Commentary : The text says to resolve the Word at the start of the close combat phase, which would be before resolving the combat the model is involved in. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp110
Die Verwundungen zählen zum Kampfergebnis.

Q50. How are hits from Word of Agony distributed against mounts and their riders?
Commentary : The text states that "a model" suffers the hits, with no guidance on how to allocate them against multi-component models such as characters on monsters or chariots. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp110
Der Chaos-Spieler wählt vor dem Würfeln, ob er den Reiter oder das Reittier treffen will, wie bei normalen Nahkampfattacken auch.

Q51. Does Diabolic Splendour apply a -1 modifier to the test or to the unit's Leadership?
Commentary : The text specifies that the modifier is to the test, but this would make it easier to pass. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp111
Die Einheit erhält natürlich -1 MW.

Q52. How are hits from Bloodcurdling Roar distributed?
Commentary : The attack occurs in the shooting phase, but is not described as shooting. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp111
Verteile die Verwundungen wie Beschuss.

Q53. Can Bloodcurdling Roar be used in a Stand and Shoot reaction?
Commentary : It is unclear whether it is considered a shooting attack suitable for such an action. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp111
Nein, da es sich hier nicht um eine Schusswaffe gemäß dem Regelbuch handelt

Q54. The Chaos Daemonsword says to roll for the effects at the start of each round. What is a round?
Commentary : "Round" is not defined in the rules. It is unclear whether the bearer should roll at the beginning of every turn, every combat phase, or just before resolving the combat he is involved in, and whether being engaged in combat is a requirement. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp112
Zu Beginn jeder Nahkampfphase (sowohl in der Eigenen, als auch in der Gegnerischen).

Q55. If a model with the Chaos Daemonsword hits and wounds himself, who if anyone gains the Combat Resolution point?
Commentary : CR is normally awarded to the side that inflicts the wounds, but the bearer will be wounding himself. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp112
Der Gegner erhält die Punkte.

Q56. How are attacks with the Hatred (or other reroll) special rule resolved against a model with Armour of Damnation?
Commentary : Dice can only be rerolled once, it is unclear how to resolve this conflict. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp113
Hebt sich gegenseitig auf.

Q57. Whip of Subversion: If you wound a monster that has a character mounted on it, can you then have the monster attack the mounted character?
Commentary : The text says "other models", but it is unclear whether riders and mounts are considered separate models for this purpose. Please clarify.
S. WoC 113
Ja, das sollte gehen.

Q58. Glaive of Putrefaction: How does the S2, T2 affect a unit of multi-wound models like Ogres?
Commentary : Such a unit would have rank and file with different statistics. Please clarify how attacks against such a unit would be resolved.
S. WoC 113
Der Einfachheit halber: Benutze das Glaive nur gegen Monster und Charaktermodelle, gegen Einheiten mit mehreren Lebenspunkten wirkt das Glaive nicht.

Q59. How is the Glaive of Putrefaction resolved against ridden monsters/chariots? Are all components reduced to S2/T2?
Commentary : The text says that "the model" is reduced to S2/T2. Riders and their mounts are single models. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp113
Behandle Reiter und Reittier getrennt.

Q60. If a model with Father of Blades is fighting a model that rerolls misses (eg Hatred), can that opponent reroll 1's to hit?
Commentary : Hatred (et al) allow rerolls of misses, however a roll of 1 versus the Father of Blades is not technically a miss.
S. WoC pp113
Der Gegner verfehlt nicht, sonder trifft sich selbst.

Q61. When is the use of the Black Tongue declared? If a model has a reroll ability (Empire Luckstone, etc) can the Black Tongue be applied before the caster has the opportunity to reroll, or must he wait until the point where a dispel attempt would normally be made?
Commentary : The timing is not clear, please clarify.
S. WoC pp114
Der Gegner hat zuerst die Möglichkeit, seinen Wurf zu wiederholen. Der Chaos-Spieler muss also warten, bis er normalerweise seinen Bannwurf machen könnte.

Q62. The Golden Eye specifies that it does not apply to mounts. Does this mean that all items that affect "the model" but do not specify that they do not affect mounts, do?
Commentary : Several items say they apply to "the model". Please clarify what this means.
S. WoC pp114
Ein Überbleibsel aus der letzten Edition, beim Goldauge ist das lediglich eine Klarstellung.

Q63. If both sides have a model with the Infernal Puppet, in what order are the affects applied? For example, can one wizard wait until after the miscast has been adjusted by his enemy before declaring that he wishes to adjust it himself?
Commentary : The timing and order is unclear, please clarify.
S. WoC pp114
Zwei Infernal Puppets heben sich gegenseitig auf, keiner darf sie benutzen.

Q64. Infernal Puppet: How does this item work with the HE Trickster pendant?
Commentary : The Trickster pendant rerolls miscast results, the Puppet adjusts them. The order is important, please clarify.
S. WoC 114 HE book pg. XX
Der Chaosspieler darf um W3 ändern, danach darf der HE-Spieler wiederholen wenn er möchte und der Chaosspieler darf abschließend WIEDER um W3 ändern.

Q65. Does the Bloodskull Pendant inflict a single hit on a multipart model (mounted character, stegadon) or one hit on each component? If a single hit, how is it distributed?
Commentary : It is unclear what "model" means in this context. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp115
Beide erhalten einen Treffer.

Q66. Bloodskull Pendant: If a character with this item is in a challenge, can he use it on those in base to base with him that are not in the challenge?
Commentary : A model can only direct attacks at his opponent in a challenge, while the item inflicts hits on all models in base contact. Please clarify this conflict.
S. WoC 115
Nur das Modell in der Herausforderung.

Q67. Is a model with the Book of Secrets considered a wizard?
Commentary : The rulebook says that any model capable of casting spells is a Wizard, however the wording of the spell implies that he is not. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp115
Er ist ein Zauberer Stufe 1, produziert aber keine Bannwürfel.

Q68. Can a model with the Book of Secrets swap his spell for the first in the lore as normal?
Commentary : The ordinary process of spell selection allows this, but the item description does not. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp115
Ja, das sollte gehen.

Q69. If a Sorceror or Sorceror Lord purchases the Book of Secrets and chooses the same lore for both the Book and their own spells, would this allow them to have a duplicate of a spell?
Commentary : It is unclear whether the random selection is part of the normal spell selection process, and whether it is affected by those rules. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp115
Nein, er erhält dann einen zusätzlichen Spruch.

Q70. If a non-Sorceror purchases the Book of Secrets, can it then be combined with an Arcane Item?
Commentary : The Book grants knowledge of a spell, which would make the model a wizard. Wizards can take arcane items. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp115
Insbesondere wegen dem Spruch-Familiar würde ich das nicht zulassen.

Q71. How many dice can a non-Sorceror who purchases the Book of Secrets use to cast a spell?
Commentary : The Book does not specify a magic level for the model, so the number of dice usable is also undefined. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp115
Da er 1 EW produziert, sollte er beim zaubern wie ein LVL1-Zauberer behandelt werden, also 2 Würfel benutzen dürfen.

Q72. What happens if a model with the Book of Secrets suffers miscast 10-11 on the miscast table?
Commentary : The model would ordinarily lose a magic level and a spell, however afterwards the model would still have the Book, and its rules would still be in effect. Infernal Puppet can cause this.
S. WoC pp115, BRB pp109
Das Buch explodiert: Das Modell verliert schlichtweg diesen Gegenstand, dadurch werden die meisten Probleme gelöst.

Q73. If a Chosen Champion carries the item Favour of the Gods, can the modifier be applied to rolls for the unit?
Commentary : The item allows the champion to adjust rolls on the table, but it is not clear whether the unit's rolls are considered "his".
S. WoC pp115,123
Laut Phil Kelly geht das, das wäre dann aber sehr mächtig. Ich würde das nicht zulassen. Favour of the gods wirkt nur auf das Modell und würde ihm was bringen, wenn er selbst einen Wurf hätte (z.B. aufgrund der Sonderregel des Altars).

Q74. Can a sorceror on Steed of Slaanesh cast magic missiles with 360 arc of sight, as the Steed has the Fast Cavalry rule?
Commentary : Magic missiles follow the rules for shooting, but ordinarily characters do not benefit from the Fast Cavalry rule. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp119
Ja, lasst ihnen doch diesen Spass 🙂

Q75. Can a character with no Mark ride in a Marked chariot?
Commentary : The rules only specify that he cannot have a different mark to the chariot, but a character with no mark does not have a different mark.
S. WoC pp124
Nein, die Regel meint: Held und Streitwagen müssen das gleiche Mal haben.

Q76. Does the Chaos Knight lance option replace their Ensorcelled Weapons completely, or simply give them lances that also benefit from the Ensorcelled Weapons rule?
Commentary : The book says that the Ensorcelled Weapons are "upgraded" to lances. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp125
Die Lanze ERSETZT die verzauberten Waffen und verbessert sie nicht.
 
#8
Noch eine Klarstellung meinerseits: Wenn der Todbringer 2W6 vorstürmen muss, dann stürmt er 2W6 vor, selbst wenn die Zwerge mit max. 6" zu langsam sind. Eine Einheit bewegt sich normalerweise immer mit der Geschwindigkeit des langsamsten Modells, aber in diesem Fall sollte man davon abrücken.

Die Kombination "Auserkorener Champion mit verfluchtem Buch" bringt auch einige Unklarheiten mit sich: Erhält er mit Mal des Tzeentch +1 auf die Komplexität? Erhalte ich +1 auf die Komplexität auf jeden Fall, wenn ich noch die Gunst erhalten (Tzeentch-Zauber, der mich zu einem richtigen Charaktermodell macht.) Zählt er als Charaktermodell, zählt er als Zauberer? Nutzt er die angegebenen Lehren oder die Lehre passend zu seinem Chaosmal? Mit Seelenraub könnte ich die Anzahl meiner Lebenspunkte verändern und mit Schattenross darf ich regelkonform aus meiner Einheit rausspringen.
 
#9
Es gibt mittlerweile 124 offene Fragen zum neuen Armeebuch.
Q1. Are duplicate results of "The Eye is Closed" rerolled?
Commentary : The rules for the Eye specify that any roll is a gift, and any duplicate gifts are rerolled.
S. WoC pp43

Q2. If a model or unit rerolls on the Eye of the Gods table and the second result is also a duplicate, can/must it be rerolled?
Commentary : The rules are very clear that no dice can ever be rerolled more than once, regardless of source.
S. WoC pp43, BRB pp1

Q3. If the answer to the above two questions are yes, what happens if a unit rolls 12 times on the table?
Commentary : There will be no result which will not be rerolled.
S. WoC pp43

Q4. If a large target flees or breaks and is run down by a character, does the character get to claim the EotG bonus?
Commentary : The Eye of the Gods rule only specifies that the character cannot simply run down enemy characters to claim the bonus.
S. WoC pp43

Q5. If a character is in a unit and an enemy model with the Large special rule is slain, must the character do the final wound to gain the roll on the Eye of the Gods table?
Commentary : The Eye of the Gods rule only specifies that the character must influct the final wound on characters.
S. WoC pp43

Q6. If the answer to the above is no, if more than one character is in a unit that kills a large target, do both the characters get to claim credit and roll on the EotG table?
S. WoC pp43

Q7. If a large target crumbles due to combat resolution (such as a zombie dragon, or greater daemon) does the character get to claim the EotG bonus?
S. WoC pp43

Q8. Does killing a champion in a challenge count for the EotG bonus?
Commentary : The rule specifies character, but it seems odd.
S. WoC pp43

Q9. What happens if a troll or model with the Helm of Many Eyes (Stupid) rolls Stupidity on the Eye of the Gods table?
Commentary : The rules say that duplicate gifts are rerolled, but do not mention whether having the rule already counts as duplication.
S. WoC. pp43.

Q10. How do rolls on the Eye of the Gods table affect mounts (either of characters or units blessed by the war shrine)?
Commentary : No indication is given either way. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp43

Q11. If a character (with the Eye of the Gods rule) is involved in a combat where there are friendly champions (without the Eye of the Gods rule), must the character challenge or can the champion?
Commentary : The rules state that the character must issue a challenge where able, but if the champion challenges then the character cannot.
S. WoC pp43

Q12. If a sorceror kills a Large Target with a spell, does he get to roll on the Eye of the Gods table?
Commentary : There appear to be no restrictions on how a character might kill a large target and qualify to roll on the table.
S. WoC pp43

Q13. Chosen: If at the beginning of the game, they roll a ‘2’ and then a ‘7’ are they stuck with that?
Commentary : Any dice may only be rerolled once.
S. WoC pp47

Q14. Do Daemon Princes or Daemonic Mounts have magical attacks?
Commentary : Other daemons do. It also seems very unusual for a Lord-level character to have no recourse to magical attacks at all, even from equipment (Flaming Sword of Rhuin notwithstanding).
S. WoC pp53,54

Q15. Are Daemon Princes Daemons for the purpose of Burning Gaze, Cleansing Flare, and other such effects?
Commentary : The Prince lacks the "normal" properties of Daemons, such as magical attacks, ward save, and instability.
S. WoC pp53

Q16. On what size base should a Steed of Slaanesh be mounted?
Commentary : The Steed is a 1-wound mount, making it cavalry. Two models exist that could be the "Steed of Slaanesh", one comes with 25x50, the other 50x50. The notes on page 54 state that the other Gods' mounts and generic Daemonic mount are not mounted on 25x50mm bases, but make no mention of the Steed of Slaanesh.
S. WoC pp54

Q17. If the Warshrine grants an EotG roll to a unit with a character in it; does the character gain the bonus as well?
Commentary : The character is part of the unit, but the Warshrine does not specify.
S. WoC pp58.

Q18. If the answer to the above is yes, what happens if/when the character leaves the unit?
Commentary : It is unclear whether the effect will continue for the unit and character, or only one of the two.
S. WoC pp58

Q19. If the Warshrine grants an EotG roll to a unit and the result is a duplicate to a previous roll the unit or a model in the unit already has, should you re-roll it?
Commentary : The Warshrine's rules do not include the "Duplicate gifts must always be rerolled" stipulation.
S. WoC pp58, 43

Q20. Does the Warshrine's Giver of Glory rule affect champions from both sides?
Commentary : The text does not specify "friendly".
S. WoC pp58

Q21. If the answer to the above is yes, what constitutes a "Chaos champion"? Do Daemons of Chaos and Beasts of Chaos count?
S. WoC pp58

Q22. If the Warshrine is destroyed or otherwise removed from play, does the last unit to be blessed by it retain the gift?
Commentary : The rules say that rerolling the result for the blessed unit negates the previous effect, but they do not specify that the effect ends if the Warshrine is slain.
S. WoC pp58

Q23. What is the Unit Strength of the War Shrine?
Commentary : It is unclear whether "moving and fighting" like a monster includes the rules for US. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp58

Q24. Is a War Shrine affected by spells, magic items or special rules that influence monsters?
Commentary : It is unclear whether "moving and fighting" like a monster includes such effects.
S. WoC pp58

Q25. If a Warshrine targets a Giant with it's Giver of Glory rule and rolls +1 Attack or +1 Strength, what happens?
Commentary : The Giant has "Special" as it's attacks value, and it's special attacks have a specified strength, so it is unclear how they will affect the Giant.
S. WoC pp58,65

Q26. If a Warshrine targets a Chariot with it's Giver of Glory rule and rolls +1 Attack or +1 Strength, what happens?
Commentary : Chariots have multiple statlines, and it is unclear how many and which would be improved by these results.
S. WoC pp58

Q27. Do wounds suffered by a Giant count to CR if they are subsequently healed by the Giant's Chomp attack in the same phase?
Commentary : On one hand they were still inflicted, on the other the Giant is not hurt by the time CR is calculated.
S. WoC pp65

Q28. If a giant rolls a double with "Thump with Club" and the combat ends that round, but he pursues/overruns into another combat, must he still forgo his attacks in the next round of combat?
Commentary : Other effects specify they do not apply if the combat ends, the "stuck club" condition does not.
S. WoC pp65

Q29. If a Giant "Hurls" a rank and file model with multiple wounds, a ward save, or regeneration and it survives, what happens?
Commentary : The resultant model is separated from its unit, a condition that cannot normally occur.
S. WoC pp65

Q30. If a Giant "Hurls" a model, does it benefit from any protective banners (eg. Drakenhof) or abilities (eg. Locus of Nurgle) in its unit?
Commentary : It isn't clear when exactly the wound is suffered.
S. WoC pp65

Q31. If a Giant is first to act in a multiple combat (either through charging into a continuing combat or through the Mark of Slaanesh) rolls Yell and Bawl, do units that are not in base contact still get to resolve their attacks?
Commentary : The Yell and Bawl rules say that models "in contact" do not get to resolve their attacks, and that the Giant's side automatically wins by 2. Some take this to mean that the combat ceases at this point and a break test is taken immediately for the losing side. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp65

Q32. If the answer to the above is yes, if two giants on opposing sides Yell and Bawl, how is the combat resolved?
Commentary : Both sides will "automatically win by 2". Please clarify.
S. WoC pp65

Q33. What happens if a giant is fighting a single model and rolls "Throw back into combat"?
Commentary : The rules say the model is thrown back into its unit, but there may not be such a unit. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp65

Q34. What happens if a Giant "Hurls" a character into a unit it cannot join?
Commentary : Characters cannot join units that are engaged in combat, Unbreakable (unless they themselves are unbreakable), Chariots, Monsters, or Flying Units etc. It is unclear what happens in these cases. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp65

Q35. If a Giant has charged a single model and rolls "Hurl", can it overrun?
Commentary : The model may survive being hurled, and thus not be wiped out.
S. WoC pp65

Q36. Do the wounds inflicted on a unit struck by a "hurled" model count towards the Giant's combat resolution?
Commentary : The unit may not be engaged in the combat, so it is unclear whether they would count.
S. WoC pp65

Q37. Are units engaged in combat with the Giant counted when determining where a victim is "Hurled"?
Commentary : There is no explicit indication, but the last sentence of "Hurl" implies that they do not.
S. WoC pp65

Q38. How are hits from a "hurled" or "thrown" result distributed?
Commentary : No indication is given, please clarify.
S. WoC pp65

Q39. If a Giant "Squashes" or "Eats" a model, how many points of combat resolution does the Giant score?
Commentary : Combat resolution requires wounds to be inflicted, "squash" and "eat" slay the model but do not inflict wounds. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp65

Q40. The Hellcannon is a monster but "fires like a stone thrower". Does this mean it is move-or-fire?
Commentary : Move-or-fire is not a rule of stone throwers but of war machines. The Hellcannon is not a war machine. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp66

Q41. The Hellcannon "fires like a stone thrower". Does losing Chaos Dwarves reduce the rate at which it can fire?
Commentary : The Hellcannon has no crew, only handlers. It is unclear whether they are to be treated as crew or whether crew is required at all.
S. WoC pp66

Q42. Can the Hellcannon "Stand and Shoot" as a charge reaction?
Commentary : The prohibition on stand and shoot is a rule of war machines, the Hellcannon is not a war machine. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp66

Q43. Do Tomb King Liche Priests suffer a miscast if the Hellcannon rolls a 3 on its misfire chart?
Commentary : Liche Priests are wizards, but do not normally miscast due to their unusual magic. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp66

Q44. If a Hellcannon misfires rolls a 3, what happens if any wizards roll the result that the other player can cast a spell for free? How (if at all) can this be dispelled?
Commentary : As the Hellcannon will misfire in the shooting phase, their will be no power or dispel dice in play.
S. WoC pp66

Q45. What base should a Hellcannon be on?
Commentary : The model is not supplied with a base, and the rules give no guidance. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp66

Q46. How are victory points awarded for the Hellcannon?
Commentary : The Hellcannon is a monster and handlers, which under the normal rules means that half the models (potentially 2 dwarfs) would need to be wiped out to score half victory points, and all models would have to be killed to score full.
S. WoC pp66

Q47. What is the charge range of a Hellcannon?
Commentary : During charges, the handlers are "completely ignored". If they are completely ignored their movement of 3" cannot slow the unit down, granting a 12" charge.
S. WoC pp66, BRB pp67

Q48. Archaon's Chosen of the Gods rule says that "enemy are at -1 to hit with attacks in close combat". Does this apply only to attacks against Archaon?
Commentary : Ordinarily the text would say "attacks against [the model]", but this condition is absent. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp69

Q49. If Archaon releases U'Zuhl and rolls one or more 1's to hit, are any wounds counted to combat resolution, and if so which side benefits?
Commentary : Combat resolution is normally awarded to the side inflicting the wounds, but Archaon will be wounding his own side. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp69

Q50. Can Galrauch join units?
Commentary : Galrauch is a character, not a monster. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp70

Q51. Can Wulfrik use Seafang to enter the table with a unit of Marauder Horsemen?
Commentary : The description says "a single unit of Marauders". It is unclear whether this means Chaos Marauders, Marauder Horsemen, or both. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp74

Q52. Can Wulfrik force a champion to accept this challenge?
Commentary : The text specifies that he can force a character to accept, but it seems strange that a champion would be immune to something a supposedly stronger-willed character would succumb to.
S. WoC pp74

Q53. Is Starcrusher a magic weapon?
Commentary : This is important for various spells and effects that target magic weapons specifically.
S. WoC pp75

Q54. Is "Herald of the Tempest" voluntary, or must it be performed every turn?
Commentary : the rule carries no optional language, and appears to be compulsory. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp75

Q55. If the answer to the above it yes, what happens if Kholek cannot see any enemy units?
Commentary : No guidance is given. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp75

Q56. Do the hits from "Herald of the Tempest" inflict D3 wounds?
Commentary : "Starcrusher" says that any wound inflicted by Kholek is multiplied to D3 wounds. The wounds from Herald of the Tempest are inflicted by Kholek.
S. WoC pp75

Q57. Does Throgg grant Kholek Suneater a reroll to Break tests?
Commentary : It is unclear whether Kholek is a monster. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp75,79

Q58. Must Scyla issue challenges?
Commentary : Eye of The Gods specifies that Chaos Models must issue challenges if able, Scyla's Hero's Fate rule says she can issue challenges. It is unclear whether Eye of the Gods forces all Chaos models to issue challenges, or only those with the rule themselves.
S. WoC pp76

Q59. Chaos lores are treated "exactly the same as lores published in the warhammer rulebook". Does this mean that any model with the ability to choose a lore from the Warhammer Rulebook can choose a Chaos lore (eg Empire Battle Wizards)?
Commentary : Treating a lore exactly as if it appears in the Rulebook has many far-reaching consequences. Was this the intent?
S. WoC pp106

Q60. Do Sorcerors and Sorceror Lords have access to magical shields?
Commentary : The rules on page 106 say that sorcerors are unusual in that they wear chaos armour and use magical armour and shields like other champions, however they have no options for shields and so cannot buy magical shields.
S. WoC pp106

Q61. Do Daemon Princes that are given magic levels get Chaos Armour?
Commentary : The rules on page 106 say that sorcerors wear Chaos Armour, and Daemon Princes with magic levels are sorcerors.
S. WoC pp106

Q62. Does the phrase "single model" in Magnificent Buboes mean that the target must not be in a unit?
Commentary : This is the normal meaning of the phrase.
S. WoC pp107

Q63. If the answer to the above is no, can the spell pick out characters in a unit? Can it be cast into combat?
Commentary : It isn't clear which, if any, targeting restrictions the spell must adhere to. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp107

Q64. Will Curse of the Leper automatically kill a war machine such as a cannon as soon as it is cast?
Commentary : Reducing a model's strength to 0 or less removes it from play. Most war machines have Strength 0, so Curse will reduce their strength to less than 0 immediately.
S.WoC pp107

Q65. Pandaemonium: If an enemy unit, character or spellcaster has magic resistance (such as a Bretonnian Damsel) can they use it when this spell is cast?
Commentary : MR applies if a unit is "affected" by a spell. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp108

Q66. How is a character on their own affected by Pandaemonium?
Commentary : The spell disallows units from using any character's Leadership. Characters on their own are units, and thus cannot benefit from their own Leadership.
S. WoC pp108

Q67. What happens if Call to Glory is cast on the last remaining non-character in a unit containing characters?
Commentary : An illegal unit would be formed as a result. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp108

Q68. What happens when Call to Glory is dispelled/ends after it has been cast?
Commentary : The spell description says to remove the target from play and replace with an Exalted Hero. No guidance is given for what happens if and when the spell ends. Possibilities include that the model is removed and replaced with the original model, or that it is simply removed, or it remains under some third set of rules.
S. WoC pp108

Q69. If the Exalted is replaced with the original rank and file model, what happens if a wound was suffered prior to the end of the spell? Is the suffered wound carried over, possibly killing the (single wound) model?
Commentary : It is unclear what effects carry over between the enchanted and mundane model.
S. WoC pp108

Q70. If an Exalted created using Call to Glory is in a challenge, and the casting player decides to end the spell, what happens?
Commentary : RiP spells can be ended at any time by the caster. If the model reverts to "rank and file" then it is in a challenge it could never have accepted/issued. If it is simply removed, then it is unclear what the effect on the challenge would be.
S. WoC pp108

Q71.Since RiP spells can be ended at any time by the caster, it seems that the casting player can end Call to Glory just before taking any saves/removing the model as a casualty and thus prevent the death of the model - it ceases to be worth 100VPs as soon as the spell ends.
In what circumstances can a player score 100VPs for killing an Exalted Champion created by Call to Glory?
Commentary :
S. WoC pp108

Q72. Can a Call to Glory Exalted Hero leave the unit he is with?
Commentary : The model is a character, and would normally be allowed to do so.
S. WoC pp108

Q73. If the answer to the above is yes, what happens if the spell is dispelled while the Hero is away from his original unit?
Commentary : If the model reverts to non-character status, then he is separated from his unit illegally.
S. WoC pp108

Q74. Infernal Gateway: If this spell has strength 11+ and the target unit has a Vampire with the Carstein Ring, does he get to use his ring?
Commentary : It is unclear whether special saves such as the Ring apply when a model is "removed from play". Please clarify.
S. WoC pp108

Q75. Infernal Gateway: If this spell rolls a strength of 11+ does it affect the steam tank?
Commentary : The Steam Tank is immune to spells without a known strength. It is unclear whether the effect is S11/S12 or not. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp108.

Q76. Does Hellshriek dispel spells that grant Immunity to Panic or Immunity to Psychology, as described under "Cancelling Spells"?
Commentary : Ordinarily, when two spells conflict directly in this way, the later spell dispels the first. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp109, BRB pp110

Q77. Is there any time limit on the Terror or attack allocation effects of Aura of Acquiescence?
Commentary : The spell only specifies a time limit for Fear. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp109

Q78. If an enemy model is in base contact with a unit which has had Aura of Acquiescence cast upon it, can the model choose to attack another target if it fails the Leadership test to allocate attacks against the unit with the Aura?
Commentary : The model takes a Ld test to allocate its attacks against the unit, it is unclear whether alternative allocation is permitted if the test is failed. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp109

Q79. Do models in the same unit take Leadership tests individually for Aura of Acquiescence?
Commentary : the spell description specifies that models test.
S. WoC pp109

Q80. If the answer to the above is "no", do characters test separately?
Commentary : Characters are considered part of the unit they are with in all respects.
S. WoC pp109

Q81. If a sorceror casts Hysterical Frenzy on a unit that is found to be more than 24" away from the caster, does it suffer D6 S3 hits at the start of each player turn?
Commentary : The range of 24" is specified only for frenzy, the damage is "in addition" to this. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp109

Q82. Mark of Nurgle: If a character with the Mark of Nurlge is in a unit with 5+ RnF models in it, do any shooters targeting the unit suffer the -1 to hit due to the MoN?
Commentary : It is unclear whether the character is being targeted in this case. Please clarify.
S. WoC 110

Q83. If a unit with WS1 (eg Zombies) is in base contact with a model with the Mark of Nurgle, it will have WS0. Can the zombies attack?
Commentary : The rules on page 5 of the rulebook say a characteristic of 0 represents no skill in that area, and go on to say that models with WS0 are hit automatically. No guidance is given for resolving that model's attacks. Ordinarily abilities like the MoN would say that they reduce the WS to a minimum of 1.
S. WoC pp110, BRB pp5

Q84. If one model in a unit is attacking a model with the Mark of Nurgle, is the entire unit at -1WS?
Commentary : The rule says units (not models) attacking models with the Mark of Nurgle are at -1WS.
S. WoC pp110

Q85. Does the -1WS for attacking a Nurgle-marked model apply when resolving the Nurgle-marked model's side's attacks?
Commentary : The rule states that units are at -1WS when directing attacks at a Nurgle based model and in base contact. It is unclear whether the penalty just makes it harder to hit the Nurgle model or if it also makes it easier for the unit to be hit in return.
S. WoC pp110

Q86. If the answer to the above is yes, what happens if the Nurgle-marked models are striking first?
Commentary : The -1WS is only triggered if the unit directs attacks at a Nurgle model - if the Nurgle unit kills enough models then they will be unable to do so.
S. WoC pp110

Q87. If a model with Word of Agony is in combat with a Dark elf unit containing an assassin, which occurs first - the Assassin's appearance or the use of the Word of Agony?
Commentary : Both occur "at the beginning of the combat phase" with no guidance on priority. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp110, DE pp61

Q88. Do wounds inflicted by Word of Agony count towards combat resolution?
Commentary : The text says to resolve the Word at the start of the close combat phase, which would be before resolving the combat the model is involved in. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp110

Q89. How are hits from Word of Agony distributed against mounts and their riders?
Commentary : The text states that "a model" suffers the hits, with no guidance on how to allocate them against multi-component models such as characters on monsters or chariots. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp110

Q90. If a model engaged in a challenge is killed at the start of the combat phase by Word of Agony, is his opponent still locked in the challenge for that round of combat?
Commentary : Challenges end when one of the antagonists is slain, it is unclear when the survivor becomes targetable again. Please clarify/
S. WoC pp110, BRB pp 77

Q91. For the purposes of "Distendable Maw", what constitutes a man-sized infantry model?
Commentary : References to "man-sized models" have been removed from other publications, and it is unclear whether a Dwarf Lord on Shieldbearers (for example) fits this description. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp110

Q92. Does Diabolic Splendour apply a -1 modifier to the test or to the unit's Leadership?
Commentary : The text specifies that the modifier is to the test, but this would make it easier to pass. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp111

Q93. Is Bloodcurdling Roar a shooting attack?
Commentary: The description specifies it is made in the shooting phase, but does not specify that it is a shooting attack. If it is a shooting attack then it cannot be used in close combat, cannot be used in the same turn as another shooting attack, cannot target units in close combat, cannot be used while marching, and has clear rules for distribution of hits. If not, then all of these things are undefined. Please clarify.

Q94. Does Soporific Musk affect the flee distance of a unit that fails a Panic, Fear, or Terror Test?
Commentary : "Fleeing from" is ambiguous. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp111

Q95. The Chaos Daemonsword says to roll for the effects at the start of each round. What is a round?
Commentary : "Round" is not defined in the rules. It is unclear whether the bearer should roll at the beginning of every turn, every combat phase, or just before resolving the combat he is involved in, and whether being engaged in combat is a requirement. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp112

Q96. If a model with the Chaos Daemonsword hits and wounds himself, who if anyone gains the Combat Resolution point?
Commentary : CR is normally awarded to the side that inflicts the wounds, but the bearer will be wounding himself. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp112

Q97. How are attacks with the Hatred (or other reroll) special rule resolved against a model with Armour of Damnation?
Commentary : Dice can only be rerolled once, it is unclear how to resolve this conflict. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp113

Q98. Whip of Subversion: If you wound a monster that has a character mounted on it, can you then have the monster attack the mounted character?
Commentary : The text says "other models", but it is unclear whether riders and mounts are considered separate models for this purpose. Please clarify.
S. WoC 113

Q99. Glaive of Putrefaction: How does the S2, T2 affect a unit of multi-wound models like Ogres?
Commentary : Such a unit would have rank and file with different statistics. Please clarify how attacks against such a unit would be resolved.
S. WoC 113

Q100. How is the Glaive of Putrefaction resolved against ridden monsters/chariots? Are all components reduced to S2/T2?
Commentary : The text says that "the model" is reduced to S2/T2. Riders and their mounts are single models. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp113

Q101. If a model with Father of Blades is fighting a model that rerolls misses (eg Hatred), can that opponent reroll 1's to hit?
Commentary : Hatred et al allow rerolls of misses, however a roll of 1 versus the Father of Blades is not technically a miss.
S. WoC pp113

Q102. Do the special rules of Father of Blades apply against shooting at the character?
Commentary : The description states that any to-hit rolls of 1 are affected, and do not limit the effect to close combat.
S. WoC pp113

Q103. When is the use of the Black Tongue declared? If a model has a reroll ability (Empire Luckstone, etc) can the Black Tongue be applied before the caster has the opportunity to reroll, or must he wait until the point where a dispel attempt would normally be made?
Commentary : The timing is not clear, please clarify.
S. WoC pp114

Q104. The Golden Eye specifies that it does not apply to mounts. Does this mean that all items that affect "the model" but do not specify that they do not affect mounts, do?
Commentary : Several items say they apply to "the model". Please clarify what this means.
S. WoC pp114

Q105. If both sides have a model with the Infernal Puppet, in what order are the affects applied? For example, can one wizard wait until after the miscast has been adjusted by his enemy before declaring that he wishes to adjust it himself?
Commentary : The timing and order is unclear, please clarify.
S. WoC pp114

Q106. Infernal Puppet: How does this item work with the HE Trickster pendant?
Commentary : The Trickster pendant rerolls miscast results, the Puppet adjusts them. The order is important, please clarify.
S. WoC pp114 HE book pg. XX

Q107. If a player declares he is using the Infernal Puppet, and rolls the D3, may he then decline to adjust the roll?
Commentary : The text says he may modify the roll by up to D3. Zero is less than D3 and so is included in "up to", however a change of zero is arguably not a modification. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp114

Q108. Does the Bloodskull Pendant inflict a single hit on a multipart model (mounted character, stegadon) or one hit on each component? If a single hit, how is it distributed?
Commentary : It is unclear what "model" means in this context. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp115

Q109. Bloodskull Pendant: If a character with this item is in a challenge, can he use it on those in base to base with him that are not in the challenge?
Commentary : A model can only direct attacks at his opponent in a challenge, while the item inflicts hits on all models in base contact. Please clarify this conflict.
S. WoC 115

Q110. Are the hits inflicted when a character activates the Bloodskull Pendant resolved with the rules of any magic weapon the model is carrying?
Commentary : The character must select a weapon at the start of combat and use it throughout.
S. Woc pp115

Q111. Is a model with the Book of Secrets considered a wizard?
Commentary : The rulebook says that any model capable of casting spells is a Wizard, however the wording of the spell implies that he is not. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp115

Q112. Can a model with the Book of Secrets swap his spell for the first in the lore as normal?
Commentary : The ordinary process of spell selection allows this, but the item description does not. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp115

Q113. If a Sorceror or Sorceror Lord purchases the Book of Secrets and chooses the same lore for both the Book and their own spells, would this allow them to have a duplicate of a spell?
Commentary : It is unclear whether the random selection is part of the normal spell selection process, and whether it is affected by those rules. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp115

Q114. If a non-Sorceror purchases the Book of Secrets, can it then be combined with an Arcane Item?
Commentary : The Book grants knowledge of a spell, which would make the model a wizard. Wizards can take arcane items. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp115

Q115. How many dice can a non-Sorceror who purchases the Book of Secrets use to cast a spell?
Commentary : The Book does not specify a magic level for the model, so the number of dice usable is also undefined. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp115

Q116. What happens if a model with the Book of Secrets suffers miscast 10-11 on the miscast table?
Commentary : The model would ordinarily lose a magic level and a spell, however afterwards the model would still have the Book, and its rules would still be in effect. Infernal Puppet can cause this.
S. WoC pp115, BRB pp109

Q117. If a marked model purchases the Book of Secrets, from which lore does he generate spells?
Commentary : Models with a mark always generate spells from the lore of their God, the book only allows non-God lores.
S. WoC pp115, 106

Q118. If a Chosen Champion carries the item Favour of the Gods, can the modifier be applied to rolls for the unit?
Commentary : The item allows the champion to adjust rolls on the table, but it is not clear whether the unit's rolls are considered "his".
S. WoC pp115,123

Q119. Can a sorceror on Steed of Slaanesh cast magic missiles with 360 arc of sight, as the Steed has the Fast Cavalry rule?
Commentary : Magic missiles follow the rules for shooting, but ordinarily characters do not benefit from the Fast Cavalry rule. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp119

Q120. Can a character with no Mark ride in a Marked chariot?
Commentary : The rules only specify that he cannot have a different mark to the chariot, but a character with no mark does not have a different mark.
S. WoC pp124

Q121. Can a character with a Mark ride in a chariot without a Mark?
Commentary : The rules only specify that he cannot have a different mark to the chariot, but a chariot with no mark does not have a different mark.
S. WoC pp124

Q122. Does the Chaos Knight lance option replace their Ensorcelled Weapons completely, or simply give them lances that also benefit from the Ensorcelled Weapons rule?
Commentary : The book says that the Ensorcelled Weapons are "upgraded" to lances. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp125

Q123. Does a Chaos Warshrine benefit from the rules for fighting with two hand weapons?
Commentary : The War Shrine has "hand weapons" as its equipment, and "fights like a monster". If monsters can benefit from extra hand weapons (see below), then the War Shrine would also qualify.
S. WoC pp126, BRB pp56

Q124. What benefit does a Shaggoth gain from purchasing an additional hand weapon?
Commentary : The rules for fighting with a weapon in each hand apply to infantry only. If monsters can also be infantry, that opens the door to them entering buildings (pun intended).
S. WoC pp127, BRB pp56
Zum Vergrößern anklicken....
 
#10
Q122. Does the Chaos Knight lance option replace their Ensorcelled Weapons completely, or simply give them lances that also benefit from the Ensorcelled Weapons rule?
Commentary : The book says that the Ensorcelled Weapons are "upgraded" to lances. Please clarify.
S. WoC pp125
Zum Vergrößern anklicken....
Wenn so die meisten Fragen aussehen (Werd doch nicht alle >=122 Fragen mir durchlesen). Dann wird man auch auf 400 und noch mehr Fragen kommen. Man muss schon lesen was im AB steht und nicht versuchen alles hochzupauschen.

Ist sowas wie die (damalige) Frage: Können Fluchritter jetzt nur noch von mag. Waffen verwundet werden?... <_<
 
#11
Hier darfst du nicht den deutschen Text heranziehen, im englischen steht es relativ eindeutig, dass die Waffen von Chaosrittern immer als verzaubert gelten, egal welche Form sie haben (also auch Lanzen). Ich müsste selbst mit verzauberten Lanzen (mit S7) überlegen, ob ich diese 5 Punkte ausgebe, oder nicht - insofern ist die Frage auch spieltechnisch berechtigt, denn ohne die +1S nimmt die keiner niemals nie mit.

RAW sind Lanzen 100% eindeutig verzaubert, die Frage ist eher, ob das von GW so gewollt war, denn daran zweifeln die Meisten.
 
#17
Oben Unten
Neueste Inhalte Folgen Zitieren
Neueste Inhalte Folgen Zitieren
Menü